I've been using Talon rubber grips for a long time and I love them. They seem to "fill the hand" a little bit more to my liking
I've been aware of Decal Grips for a while, found a one for rather cheap so I thought to give the rubber version a try. It isn't hugely grippy like the sandpaper, but it's good enough. It is a thicker rubber than Talons. I don't think they'll end up peeling a little sooner than Talons just because of their design. But I've used them for a couple months now with it not failing.
Since its a non-permanent mod and they're not very expensive, they're worth a try at least once.