Avoid the poly buffer. Gun don't need it and it does nothing for felt recoil.
The other buffer is like the factory and will give you best results. They've had some good remarks here and in other places. Outside of the B. Springfield buffer your next best choice would be an original HK heavy two stage buffer like that used in the PSG1 and the HK21.
A forum dedicated to and laser-focused on Heckler & Koch firearms, Heckler & Koch accessories and the owners and enthusiasts that love them! Come join the discussion regarding HK pistols, long arms, NFA arms, HK accessories, HK history and trivia and more.