The new HK designs
If you ask me, I think HK had it right with the first HK45 prototypes. Even Larry Vickers says so, and he participated in its design!
But someone "wiser" than Vickers decided they needed the sculpted grips.
Some VP at HK probably thought the prototype wasn't evolutionary enough to garner attention. So ergo-grips to the rescue.. Arg!
I like the adjustable backstraps, but if I wanted scuplted grips I'd buy rubberized grips myself, thankyou. I like the longer mag-release. I like the new design of the safety-decock lever and slide-release levers. I like the 1913 rail -- they should have done that ages ago. All good improvements.
But I think HK afficionados really don't want to see such a huge appearance leap, such as from the USP to the P30... What say you?
To me the P30 is too "curvy" and I don't prefer ergo-grip designs. The HK45 prototype shown below kept the USP family resemblance, but improved it in several ways. Like having slide serations on the front and rear of the slide. I like improving functionality while not distracting from a good-looking design.
If I were VP of design at HK:
I'd take the initial HK45 prototype (shown in the photo below), then make it in black as well as stainless, just like the USP. I'd offer it in 9mm and .40S&W as well. Why not? Both rounds sell more than the .45 ACP.
The Clinton-Brady ban is over, so we can have our 18-round magazines (like I do with my 9mm USPs).
Because I'm left-handed (12% of the population is) but mainly shoot right-handed (the other 88%), I prefer an ambidextrous safety decock lever. I can shoot either way, so why can't my HK?
Judging by the huge sales of 1911 ambi-safety devices, apparently others like it too. It's one of the first things people add to their 1911.
And it's what I really like about my Expert. So I'd offer my design standard with ambi-safety & ambi-slide release lever.
Offer it with or w/o the extended barrel. Many have no use for supressors, even if it does look cool with the extended barrel.
Of course the o-ring would be standard, and if you could fit the polymer buffer to the recoil guide rod and spring in 9mm and .40S&W, then that would be standard as well.
So, you'd have the HK45, HK40, and HK9, available in Army Earth color, Black on Black, or Black with Stainless Steel slide. All versions would come with the field-durable dot-sights, for better quick aiming, and with a tall front sight, if the need for a supressor should later arise.
I don't know how the HK45 trigger feels, but if it can replicate the feel of a match-trigger, terrific.
So, if HK produced this pistol described above, resembling the photo below,
(1) would you buy it? and
(2) in what Color/Caliber/Barrel?