HKPRO Forums banner

MP5 / SP5 Red Dots, Mounts, and Co-Witness Thread

124K views 107 replies 52 participants last post by  Valleshtr  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Here is my attempt to gather all the information on MP5 Red Dots and Mounts. I have threatened to make a one-stop thread and here I am! Since I got the MP5 bug I found myself searching for this info. Then once I had a few mounts/optics under my belt I would comment here on Pro or Arfcom. The same questions always seem to come up so maybe we can get them all answered here.

The AR platform has a standard of absolute co-witness and 1/3 co-witness. There is no such standard with the MP5 but I will try to relate my findings to these standards.

Absolute co-witness means that if you are perfectly aligned with your optic, the irons are also lined up in the center of the optic. Any other setup, means the irons are either above or below the red dot, or not in the view at all.

If the irons can still be seen through the optic, you can get a co-witness when you go off axis on the red dot and use manufacturers' "parallax free" ability. I use parenthesis because it has been shown that most, if not all, red dots have parallax the further you get from the center of the optic. Green Eye Tactical did some good work on this topic:

https://www.greeneyetactical.com/2017/07/27/comparative-study-of-red-dot-sight-parallax/

I do not have the height of the basic iron above bore numbers for the MP5. I gathered data from manufacturers where I could with respect to optical height for their mounts and these are the numbers I discuss below.

My own MP5 experience is this: I own a Z-5P (MP5K-PDW) that came with an optic rail. I have owned the B&T 10266 & 21241 and the MFI Low Mount. EDIT: I have a full-size AT94P now as well. But of course, this all applies to both models. On the full-size, I am using the 21241 and Holosun micro.

Absolute Co-Witness
Battle Steel direct mount. This looks really low and could be absolute co-witness. I have never seen one in real life but I did test the MRO mount further down this post. Confirmed by user Dragnet, this is absolute co-witness:
(image unavailable)

RMR direct mount to rear sight. This option replaces the rear sight with a mount designed for the RMR. Yup, this can't be called co-witness since there is no rear sight. How about: this is "absolute co-witness" height.

Pics from Oicani.
Image

Image



How to get close to 1/3 Co-Witness
The lowest MP5 adapter rails I know about are the B&T 10266 (short) and the B&T 21241 (long). MFI has something called the Ultra Low and I believe these are as low as the B&T. I also believe the welded-on rails are about the same height as these rails but cannot confirm that.

Mount/Optic Combo
Aimpoint Micro factory H1/T1 mount, non-QD - 18mm (~0.71") optical height
+
Aimpoint Micro H1/T1 or clones like the Holosun/PA.
=
~1/3 Co-Witness, I suppose the red dot is about halfway between the front sight and the bottom of the front sight hood.

NOTE: You can buy a QD upgrade/latch for those mounts. Botach sells a kit as well.

B&T 21241 + Holosun + Aimpoint Low Mount (non-QD)



The dot is closer to the hood if you use the Aimpoint LRP QD without a spacer. This mount is rated at 20mm which is 2mm higher than the original low mount. It makes a difference! I have one of these and learned the hard way that it was higher than the non-QD.

Next up are the Aimpoint 30mm Optics with a Low Ring (21mm optical height per Vortex and Aimpoint). This is pretty close to the hood and I can see why guys cut off the hood with these setups.

Shown below is the PA 30mm Clone in a Vortex Low Ring:




From user CZ-75:
Image

Image


A new option: the direct mounts from Battle Steel (aka Botach). This MRO on the direct mount is about the same height as the 30mm Optic and Low Ring above.



Shown below is the PA 30mm Clone in a Vortex Low Ring BUT with the Zenith Rail, which put the dot above and clear of the sight hood. Very usable with decent cheek weld. NO co-witness as shown below.



EDIT: I removed my conclusions. Leaving this thread purely just information.

MRO on Trijicon factory low mount 25mm or 0.985" optical height.

On the low rails 10266/21241 this puts the dot on the hood. On the supplied Zenith Rail, which I think is the same height as the SP5K rail, the dot clears the hood. I used this initially and it worked great.





More to follow:
- Fast Fire 3 on supplied low mount. No numbers and I remember the dot on the hood with the low rails.


/moderator edit:

See also this thread for further pictures:

 
#2 ·
More on Micro Clones and Mounts

Note that I use Aimpoint mounts only for these clones.

On the left is a Sig Romeo5 + Aimpoint Micro LRP Mount. On the right is a Holosun HS403GL + Aimpoint Low Mount.

Aimpoint states the optical height of the Micro LRP is 20mm. The non-QD Aimpoint Low Mount (newer square version) is 18mm. What I didn't notice in the past is the "body" of the Sig Romeo5 is also higher than the Holosun. I took a measurement when mounted on that rail and the Sig is 3mm higher (so 2mm from the mount and assume 1mm from the body).


 
#5 · (Edited)
Thanks. OP is updated.

Absolute cowitness is a misnomer as there's no rear sight. That said, thanks for the posts and especially pics!
Haha, very true. I made some changes to the OP! Good catch.

Now that that the KAC rail/system is coming online again it would be great to see where both the 30mm and the rail put the optics.

EDIT:
Found this picture but I cannot remember the deal with the Fast Fire 3. Offhand, I want to say it was still not as low as the Micros but obviously its lower than the MRO/Low mount (~25mm). I hate to guess, but I remember the dot being on the hood with that Zenith mount. Not sure where it would be on the 21241/10266. I am using that optic on a pistol but if I get bored I can move it over to the MP5 and see whats what.

 
#7 ·
Here's another mount for the Trijicon RMR which replaces the rear sight that's advertised to give full co-witness. I believe a couple members have this setup. I have an SP5K arriving this week along with an RMR type 2 and the mount I'm describing. Here's a link to the mount that is sold on Gunbroker below. I have no vested interest in the product or seller, just providing a different mount for information's sake.

https://www.gunbroker.com/item/750621194
 
#11 ·
#19 ·
My set up after a lot of research. Think its going to work out great. I can still aim with my irons thru the precision scope mount. Holosun he507c-gr green Dot on a 45 Arisaka offset mount for up close and personal as well as a back up to the Steiner px4i 1-4 which I can still use for cqb and zoom in for positive target id and precision shot if need be. Can't wait to get to the range and try this set up out. My first time posting something online hope it works right, if not my apologies in advance.
 

Attachments

#21 ·
Sorry to revive this thread, but has anyone tried that Shield SMS with their mount that was listed above?

https://www.shieldpsd.com/shop-2/shield-mini-sight-sms-1moa-dot
https://www.shieldpsd.com/shop-2/sms-mount-for-hk-mp5

Its a pretty sweet looking idea. I'm leaning towards reflex site over microdot for my mp5 as I don't see myself needing the additional ruggedness of a microdot and yet I like the smaller frame of most reflex sites to let me see more. Not sure how I feel about lower 1/3 cowitness versus higher and more out of the way. Seems like the lower 1/3 might be a bit cluttered. Not a big fan of the idea of cowitness with how much it obstructs the view.
 
#22 ·
I just picked up the MFI low pro mount for my SP5 SBR. I have to say that this is by far one of the best aftermarket mounts I’ve seen and used. In the military we were issued the HK claw mount and it worked great to be able to still retain the use of the irons. I was definitely not going to spend the asking for that mount or the HK Factory Mount. I went on a search and found that most of you were using this exact MFI Mount and were very happy with it. If you don’t know which one I’m referring to click on this link https://mfiap.com/i-23899698-mfi-sp...le-and-the-end-of-the-rail-price-includes-usps-priority-shipping-insurance.html it will take you straight to it. I will need to mount my Aimpoint Micro to it and go zero it this weekend. Thank you for helping me decide on another alternative to the HK factory mounts.
 

Attachments

#23 ·
New Guy Here,

I use the Burris Fast Fire 3 on my PTR clone. I get what you would call 1/3rd co-witness. Im not a fan. I have the integrated Picatinney rail on the upper so Im looking for something with a lower profile. In the mean time I grabbed an A3 Tactical Riser so I can use both Red Dot and Iron sights. Im hoping I dont have to adjust my check to stock position.
 
#24 · (Edited)
Welcome to the site. Although this is an HK site, we welcome all. If you cruse the forum lists you will see there is a sub forum specifically for clone weapons. Your question may be better off asked in there due to fact your optic rail is welded vs removable. Your options are limited due to that fact vs the HK where you can get various hgt rails to aid in adjusting your optic hgt.

Edit: Not meant as a discouragement, there many knowledge wealthy folks in here that are more then willing to help. My original statement was just a mere suggestion. :wink:
 
#26 ·
Just recently received my German version SP5. I've used MP5s at work and already owned an old HK94 with the vintage but reliable Beeman's SS scope.

I had an old Aimpoint Comp M2 that I thought I'd throw on the SP5. I bought an MFI low mount made for the SP5, even has cutouts to see the serial numbers. Fine quality and mounted solidly. I only had a GG&G cantilevered mount for the M2 and when mounted it totally blocked the irons.
 

Attachments

#27 ·
I found an old Aimpoint ultra low mount base designed for the MP5. It was nicely made and sat lower than the MFI base (which is available with instructions and allen wrench, PM me). I used a Vertex 30mm ring on the Aimpoint and it worked out great. The vertex ring looks just like the one Aimpoint used to sell but discontinued. I can see the irons through the Aimpoint although not true co-witnessing. At least if the red dot fails, I can still draw a bead on my target. I'm really pleased with this solid set up.
 

Attachments

#32 · (Edited)
Here's what I've been playing around with:

My favorite for the time being is the Eotech 512 on B&T 21222 mount. This combo puts the optic's view above the triple tree for a cleaner sight picture, but because of that you're resting in between cheek and chin weld instead of a full cheek weld:
Image

Image


Next is the same BT-21222 mount with an Aimpoint PRO mounted in their 10830 high ring (discontinued). I've searched everywhere for their 10818 low ring but couldn't find one as that's been discontinued too. Although the Aimpoint ring has a thumbscrew for mounting, it really needs to be tightened down with a screw driver to keep the optic from shifting.
As you can see the triple tree is somewhat obtrusive (between cheek-chin weld height), but it's not too bad:
Image

Image


Then I tried the BT-10266 Aimpoint mount with the PRO. I think this is the lowest mount B&T has for this platform:
Image

Image


Co-witness? Not a chance! The 10818 low ring might give me a lower 1/3, but then again I prefer a cleaner sight picture. I might try a low Weaver 30mm scope ring at some point if I find one for cheap for curiosity's sake.
Image



And then........just for kicks here's an Elcan SU230/PVS. The eye relief is so bad on these things you'll probably get better results with a straw 🤣
Image



Ultimately I'd like to try some more "classical" setups, like a Trijicon RX01/RX06 or maybe even a C-More Railway. I think I've played too many video games where they had this type of setup and it's given me an itch to scratch as those were my go-to's lol.

I might even try going for a Trijicon SRO. I've seen some where it's mounted in place of the rear sight drum, but I'd like to see it up front on the rail.
 
#34 ·
I wish I would have kept my RMR on a LEAP, would have been the best of both worlds. I am 100% over trying to get a co-witness with irons across all rifle/carbine platforms. I must not be the only one seeing how popular the 1.93 mounts are for the AR these days. Currently use a T-2 on a 1.93 LEAP and love the heads up shooting position.

I just installed an MRO on the MP5 with a 1.93 Reptilia. You cannot see the front sight at all in the sight picture but I have not shot this setup yet. If I can find a cheap Aimpoint Micro LEAP mount (1/3 height probably) then that would cover both irons usage and red dot usage on the MP5. This MRO setup is going to live somewhere else.

But yeah, its a damn sky scraper mount!
 
#37 ·
I had several things I wanted when I decided to add an optic. I wanted to be able to use my iron sights with some kind of co-witness, and I wanted quick detach capability for my optic on top of the H&K brand picatinny mount. I just like the overall versatility of the set-up. I ended up getting a Trijicon MRO Pro mounted on a KZ Ultra-Low QR mount on top of my HK picatinny mount. The KZ mount is the weakest part of the set-up, but the MRO seems to hold zero no matter how many times I remove it and put it back on (which I do a lot), so I've been happy with everything. Not being able to co-witness the sights was never an option.
 
#46 ·
It would almost require a revolutionary new type of optic to sit that low. Even with the Battle Steel mount, there is very little height left to put something like a LEAP mount on and still be able to see over the surface of the bottom of the mount to use the irons. Once again, however, still no co-witnessing of any kind in this scenario. I don't know why I complain, the SP5 is awesome without sights of any kind, including the irons.
 
#47 ·
The lowest mount on the market and only one that gives the absolute cowitness is the BattleSteel thread on mount from Botach and the Aimpoint micro series. I used the Aimpoint T2.

Image
 

Attachments

#53 ·
Posted this in the Scalarworks mount thread, and figured others may see it here:

Goal: Aimpoint Micro Pattern (H/T/Holoson/PA) mount that could 1) Be mounted to the lowest profile claw mounts, 2) have a window to look through the mount and use irons/diopter whilst mounted, and 3) put the red dot just slightly over the front sight hood. Of course the Scalarworks mounts work, but I did not want the "front canted" look on my Century AP5S-K. I wanted pure vertical.

The main consideration for this was that the BattleSteel ultra low profile from Botach only has 3 slots for pic. It also has a taper on the front and rear portions of the pic edges that limit the overall length of the mount you can use with it. Since it was the lowest and the price is great, I wanted to see if I could find something that made it work.

Unfortunately, only having the 3 pic slots negated the main mount I had in mind: the Battle Arms Development mount. I have several of these mounts for MROs and really like them. However, the 2 screws and spacing doesn't allow it to work with the Battlesteel claw. I did much later find out that MKE makes a claw that is low profile and continuous pic. It looks pretty low profile, so if there is a mount combo you want to use such as the BAD, Unity, or other that needs more pic, I'd definitely look into this one.
MKE Claw: MKE AP5-P AP5-M Optic Mount SALE - AtlanticFirearms.com

Quick Aside on the BAD Mount
There are plenty of negative reviews about them online, primarily from the fact that they included screws that were too long for the MRO and people were breaking them off in the optics. Either Trijicon changed the mounting holes after their development of the mount, had inconsistent mounting hole depths (unlikely, but this is what BAD told customers which pissed them off), or some combination. The world may never know the truth, but it's definitely hurt BAD's reputation.
BAD mount: Aimpoint Lightweight Optic Mount - Absolute Co-Witness

The Solution
So this meant that the optic mount needed to be a more clamp and single screw style. Well low and behold I had purchased an AR9 from a buddy with a Holosun 403 on it. So I started eyeballing the mount... hmmm..
Image


The important part is at the bottom here, the center screw.
Image


However the length of the mount is a problem. You have to take the screw and respective locking piece off the mount, center it, and rock it on. And by doing so, you will remove a slight bit of metal from the Battlesteel claw mount. Barely any though, not enough to matter. If it doesn't rock right on, grab a very light rubber mallet and give it a few taps. Once it knocks that slight bit off the edge of the Battlesteel claw, it's easier to rock on and off. So it fits! But it was lower 1/3 and I wanted absolute. So I searched more, and found that Right To Bear sells the PA mount in absolute for cheap.

6061 and made in China, but funny enough a 3 year warranty from PA. For 30 bucks, I tried it. Worked out GREAT.
Image


Now the plan was to acquire a T2 for this gun, the Holosun was just a proof of concept really. Wasn't sure how I felt about mounting a T2 on a Chinese PA mount. So a few days later of course, I am looking at B&T's website for handguards for my SP5, and find this:B&T QD mount "Skeleton" for Aimpoint T Series 39mm

WHY DIDN'T ANYONE TELL ME THIS EXISTED!?!?!? Ordered it immediately, they had it to my house in like 2 days, and it is absolute ART. Already test fit it and confirmed it works. Window is perfect to look through to use your BUIS. Now, time to order my T2!
Image


Hope this helps folks wanting to run a similar setup but have options other than the Scalarworks.